News comes this morning that Eagles -
Their Greatest Hits 1971-1975 has again regained the title of best selling album of all time, overtaking Michael Jackson's
Thriller, which had previously de-throned it.
Many online opinionators were dismissive of the announcement, noting that the Eagles' release was a compilation of hits from their first four albums (which preceded their landmark
Hotel California record), while Thriller was a single work. Dissention noted, the Eagles' Hotel California, their next release after Greatest Hits, and not a compilation, earned #3 status on the same list.
It's inevitable that many, this writer included, have internal biases relating to what artists and style of music they prefer. However,
the RIAA rankings are based on sales/downloads/streams, not on subjective factors. I was somewhat surprised that
Rumours did not score above its #10 ranking, that
The Wall was #6 instead of
Dark Side of the Moon (not in the top 20), and that Lennon/McCartney's records were not in the top 10 (the
White Album and
The Beatles 1967-1970 ranked #12 and #18, respectively). Incidentally, Zeppelin's
IV was #5, and
Physical Graffiti #20 (tied with Metallica), and piano men Joel and John each have a compilation in the top 20.
Framed inscribed CD covers on my wall...
My inscribed
Frampton Comes Alive and
Blue Sky Night Thunder did not make the top 20. Pity.
*
After the Thrill is Gone is a song from One of These Nights