...if he were alive, would possibly be suing General Motors today for using his name in conjunction with their electric car (GM does not call it a hybrid since the gas engine is not mechanically coupled to the drivetrain).
After reading a post over on
Thunder Tales about the Volt, and having taken a brief test ride (with #1 son driving) in one last weekend at the airshow, I thought I'd do a little analysis of this vaunted new 'green' car technology, since I am (and so are you) kind of a shareholder in the company that makes this vehicle.
The car itself is inoffensive, and not uncomfortable - about the same form factor as the company's Cruze. But, selling at a price point about $15-20,000 more than a comparably equipped conventionally powered Cruze, the question arises: Is it worth it?
Chevy says the car has a range of about 35 miles on a charge. Go beyond that, and the gas engine kicks in to power the generator to run the electric motors - becoming, essentially, a 35 mpg car, which is not too shabby. But, for the sake of the analysis, we'll stick with the assumption that one's daily driving is roughly equivalent to the car's battery range.
The table below shows annual fuel spend for gas powered vehicles, based on average daily (7/365) miles driven, at various fuel efficiencies.
@ $3.25/gallon | 25 mpg | 30 mpg | 35 mpg | 40 mpg |
25 miles/day | 1186 | 989 | 847 | 741 |
30 miles/day | 1424 | 1186 | 1017 | 890 |
35 miles/day | 1661 | 1384 | 1186 | 1038 |
40 miles/day | 1898 | 1582 | 1356 | 1186 |
Basically, we see a range of $741 to $1,898, at today's typical unleaded gas price of $3.25 per gallon.
Chevy's website advertises "about $1.50 a day" for charging the batteries on the Volt. Their assumption of 12¢/kWh for electricity, found in the footnotes, appears to be reasonable. So, if one's driving is within the range delivered by the battery only, the annual anticipated spend (for electricity), would be $548.
Subtracting the electricity cost from the range of conventional vehicle fuel costs, we get $193 to $1,350 as the cost penalty for driving a gas-powered vehicle - but [even for non-business majors], does that penalty, extended over a typical six year ownership ($1,158 to $8,500), justify a front end premium (and/or interest carry) of $15-20,000 of your family's hard-earned money?
Doesn't look like it to me.